We recently did a member-only webinar where we had a great time “building” a mock note portfolio. It was fun not only to build, but also to assess what type of investor you are, so…
Most note investors can tell you what they like. Good equity. Plenty of seasoning. Strong collateral. A decent yield. A healthy discount. Easy foreclosure laws. Preferably all of it wrapped neatly into one deal.
That sounds great until you actually have to choose between them. Spoiler alert: It is also what makes the note industry amazing.
Real note buying involves tradeoffs. Sometimes the note with the best equity has the lowest yield. Sometimes the biggest discount comes with very little seasoning. Sometimes the property you like least has numbers you like the most. The question is not whether you like risk. Every investment has some. The question is which risks you are willing to accept and what you expect in return.
So let’s find out what kind of note investor you actually are.
Below are seven note-buying decisions. In each round, you must buy Note A or Note B. You cannot buy both, and you cannot skip one. Assume you have enough capital to purchase every note you select. Write down your answer before moving to the next round. Do not jump ahead to the scoring unless you enjoy ruining perfectly good quizzes. The objective is to build the portfolio you would actually want to own.
Equity and Seasoning vs. Discount and Rate
Note A
| Sales Price | $240,000 |
| Down Payment | 30% |
| Interest Rate | 8.50% |
| Payment | $1,458 |
| Seasoning | 24 months |
| Current Balance | $161,000 |
| Purchase Price | $148,000, 92% of balance |
| Property | Single-family home |
| Location | Suburban |
| Foreclosure | Non-judicial |
Note B
| Sales Price | $240,000 |
| Down Payment | 10% |
| Interest Rate | 12.50% |
| Payment | $2,454 |
| Seasoning | 3 months |
| Current Balance | $215,000 |
| Purchase Price | $161,500, 75% of balance |
| Property | Single-family home |
| Location | Suburban |
| Foreclosure | Judicial |
This is your first glimpse into what you value. Note A gives you considerably more borrower equity, two years of payment history, and a non-judicial foreclosure process. Note B gives you a much higher interest rate and a substantially deeper discount, but the borrower put down less money and you have very little payment history.
Marketability vs. Better Numbers
Note A
| Sales Price | $210,000 |
| Down Payment | 15% |
| Interest Rate | 9.50% |
| Payment | $1,664 |
| Seasoning | 18 months |
| Current Balance | $174,000 |
| Purchase Price | $153,000, 88% of balance |
| Property | Single-family home |
| Location | City |
| Foreclosure | Judicial |
Note B
| Sales Price | $180,000 |
| Down Payment | 35% |
| Interest Rate | 12.00% |
| Payment | $1,288 |
| Seasoning | 7 months |
| Current Balance | $116,000 |
| Purchase Price | $98,500, 85% of balance |
| Property | Single-family home |
| Location | Rural |
| Foreclosure | Non-judicial |
Note A gives you more seasoning and an urban property. Note B gives you much more borrower equity, a higher interest rate, a slightly better discount, and a non-judicial foreclosure process. The catch is less seasoning and a rural location.
Improved Land vs. Raw Land
Note A
| Sales Price | $120,000 |
| Down Payment | 20% |
| Interest Rate | 9.00% |
| Payment | $864 |
| Seasoning | 9 months |
| Current Balance | $95,000 |
| Purchase Price | $83,500, 88% of balance |
| Property | Improved, buildable land |
| Location | Suburban |
| Foreclosure | Non-judicial |
Note B
| Sales Price | $90,000 |
| Down Payment | 50% |
| Interest Rate | 13.50% |
| Payment | $543 |
| Seasoning | 37 months |
| Current Balance | $43,000 |
| Purchase Price | $31,000, 72% of balance |
| Property | Raw land |
| Location | Rural |
| Foreclosure | Non-judicial |
Note B has numbers that are hard to ignore. The borrower put 50% down, has been paying for more than three years, the rate is 13.5%, and you can buy the note for 72% of the remaining balance. Of course, your collateral is raw rural land. Note A costs more relative to the balance and carries a lower rate, but the collateral is improved, buildable land in a suburban market.
Stronger Borrower Position vs. Bigger Discount
Note A
| Sales Price | $280,000 |
| Down Payment | 30% |
| Interest Rate | 10.50% |
| Payment | $1,957 |
| Seasoning | 30 months |
| Current Balance | $188,000 |
| Purchase Price | $169,000, 90% of balance |
| Property | Duplex |
| Location | City |
| Foreclosure | Judicial |
Note B
| Sales Price | $250,000 |
| Down Payment | 8% |
| Interest Rate | 9.50% |
| Payment | $2,144 |
| Seasoning | 6 months |
| Current Balance | $228,000 |
| Purchase Price | $178,000, 78% of balance |
| Property | Single-family home |
| Location | Suburban |
| Foreclosure | Non-judicial |
Note A has a much larger original down payment and two and a half years of seasoning. Note B has only 8% down and six months of payment history, but you are buying at a much deeper discount and getting a suburban single-family property in a non-judicial state.
Great Numbers on Different Collateral
Note A
| Sales Price | $150,000 |
| Down Payment | 40% |
| Interest Rate | 13.00% |
| Payment | $1,054 |
| Seasoning | 11 months |
| Current Balance | $89,000 |
| Purchase Price | $67,000, 75% of balance |
| Property | Manufactured home with land |
| Location | Rural |
| Foreclosure | Non-judicial |
Note B
| Sales Price | $280,000 |
| Down Payment | 15% |
| Interest Rate | 8.50% |
| Payment | $2,065 |
| Seasoning | 33 months |
| Current Balance | $224,000 |
| Purchase Price | $206,000, 92% of balance |
| Property | Single-family home |
| Location | City |
| Foreclosure | Judicial |
This one tests how much property type and marketability matter to you. Note A gives you 40% down, a 13% rate, and a 25% discount from the current balance. The tradeoff is a manufactured home with land in a rural market. Note B gives you a city single-family house and nearly three years of seasoning, but you are paying 92% of the current balance for an 8.5% note.
Townhouse vs. Condo
Note A
| Sales Price | $220,000 |
| Down Payment | 20% |
| Interest Rate | 9.50% |
| Payment | $1,641 |
| Seasoning | 20 months |
| Current Balance | $171,000 |
| Purchase Price | $153,500, 90% of balance |
| Property | Townhouse |
| Location | Suburban |
| Foreclosure | Non-judicial |
Note B
| Sales Price | $200,000 |
| Down Payment | 35% |
| Interest Rate | 12.50% |
| Payment | $1,477 |
| Seasoning | 14 months |
| Current Balance | $128,000 |
| Purchase Price | $102,500, 80% of balance |
| Property | Condominium |
| Location | City |
| Foreclosure | Judicial |
Note A gives you more seasoning, a suburban townhouse, and a non-judicial process. Note B gives you more equity, a higher rate, and a substantially better purchase discount, but the collateral is a condo and foreclosure would be judicial.
Safe and Expensive vs. Cheap and Very New
Note A
| Sales Price | $450,000 |
| Down Payment | 35% |
| Interest Rate | 8.50% |
| Payment | $2,538 |
| Seasoning | 27 months |
| Current Balance | $279,000 |
| Purchase Price | $264,500, 95% of balance |
| Property | Single-family home |
| Location | Suburban |
| Foreclosure | Non-judicial |
Note B
| Sales Price | $150,000 |
| Down Payment | 5% |
| Interest Rate | 14.00% |
| Payment | $1,772 |
| Seasoning | 1 month |
| Current Balance | $142,000 |
| Purchase Price | $92,500, 65% of balance |
| Property | Single-family home |
| Location | Rural |
| Foreclosure | Judicial |
This might be the clearest test in the entire quiz. Note A has 35% down, 27 months of seasoning, suburban collateral, and a non-judicial foreclosure process. You are also paying 95% of the remaining balance. Note B gives you a 14% note at just 65% of the remaining balance, but the borrower put down only 5%, has made one month of payments, the property is rural, and foreclosure would be judicial.
Now Let’s See What Type of Note Investor You Are
Each note carried a hidden risk score. The scoring system weighs equity and investment-to-value at 30%, seasoning at 20%, property type and marketability at 20%, judicial versus non-judicial foreclosure at 15%, and purchase price and discount at 15%.
The score is not designed to tell you whether a note is “good” or “bad.” It is designed to show you the type of risk you repeatedly chose while building the portfolio.
| Round | Note A | Note B |
|---|---|---|
| Round 1 | 2 points | 7 points |
| Round 2 | 6 points | 4 points |
| Round 3 | 3 points | 4 points |
| Round 4 | 4 points | 7 points |
| Round 5 | 4 points | 3 points |
| Round 6 | 3 points | 5 points |
| Round 7 | 2 points | 8 points |
The Conservative Note Investor
The Balanced Note Investor
The Opportunity-Focused Note Investor
The Aggressive Note Investor
Your Score Is Not a Grade
This is probably the most important part of the quiz. A 23 is not automatically better than a 34, and a 38 does not mean you need adult supervision before buying another note. The purpose is to see whether the portfolio you naturally built matches the way you think you invest.
Look back at your seven decisions. Did you consistently choose equity over yield? Did a big enough discount make you suddenly become comfortable with things you normally say you avoid? Did rural property bother you? Manufactured housing? Condos? Judicial foreclosure? Did two years of seasoning make you willing to pay significantly more for a note?
More importantly, would you actually want to own all seven notes you selected at the same time?
That is where this gets more useful than simply evaluating seven individual deals. A note can make perfect sense by itself, but a portfolio can slowly become concentrated in ways you never intended. You can end up owning mostly rural property, mostly lightly seasoned notes, mostly judicial states, or a collection of very safe notes that you purchased at prices that leave little room for additional return.
The goal is not to avoid every risk. The goal is to understand the risk you are choosing.



Very interesting, enlighening and fun! I scored a 26. I’m a stickler for buying notes secured by property in states with non-judicial foreclosure process so I play it safe in that regard and I am willing to give up some perks for it! Once upon a time I was a substitute trustee and sold properties on the courthouse steps for a 5 county area in Texas so I am definitely comfortable with the non-judicial process and I’ve also heard too many horror stories from my friends who have had to foreclose in judicial foreclosure states.
Nice. I’m glad you liked it. Tracy and I tend to stick to Non-Judicial as well…but…if the numbers are really good, not opposed. 🙂